diff --git a/inc/models/class-checkout-form.php b/inc/models/class-checkout-form.php
index 0a1943b2..b0cf64bf 100644
--- a/inc/models/class-checkout-form.php
+++ b/inc/models/class-checkout-form.php
@@ -1032,9 +1032,7 @@ public static function convert_steps_to_v2($steps, $old_settings = []) {
 
 				$old_template_list = is_array($old_template_list) ? $old_template_list : [];
 
-				$template_list = array_flip($old_template_list);
-
-				$template_list = ! empty($template_list) ? $template_list : $templates;
+				$template_list = ! empty($old_template_list) ? $old_template_list : $templates;
 
 				$step['fields'] = [
 					'template_selection' => [